Short answer: usually not, and usually not more expensive either. For six hotels in five countries, the hotel's own website charged the same as Booking.com and Expedia, give or take 1%, on five of the six. The cheapest price for every hotel came from a smaller reseller, between 4% and 22% below the hotel's own site, and almost none of those cheap rates could be cancelled for free.
We priced one identical stay: one night on Tuesday 8 December 2026, two adults, in US dollars, viewed from the United States. All prices were collected on 9 November 2026.
Key findings
- The hotel's own site and the big booking sites charged almost the same. At 5 of the 6 hotels that showed a direct price, Booking.com and Expedia were within 1% of it.
- Two exceptions stood out. At the Bellagio in Las Vegas, Booking.com was 4.8% higher than the hotel's own site ($468.03 against $446.50). At Hilton Tokyo, Hotels.com ($403.78) and Agoda ($405.20) were about 9% higher than the hotel's site ($370.34), even though Expedia, which belongs to the same group as Hotels.com, matched it.
- The cheapest seller was never the hotel or a major booking site. Lesser-known resellers undercut the hotel's own price by 3.6% (Hilton Tokyo) to 21.9% (Park Plaza Westminster Bridge, London).
- The cheapest rates were non-refundable. None of the six lowest offers included free cancellation. At the Bellagio, the hotel's own rate did.
- Each hotel had a lot of sellers. Each of the six hotels with a direct price listed between 20 and 34 different sellers for the same room-night.
- A member rate can be the direct price. At three hotels (Pullman Paris Tour Eiffel, Hotel Arts Barcelona and Park Plaza), the direct price shown was a members-only rate.
The numbers
Prices are the total per night as shown to a US visitor, with taxes and mandatory fees where the seller itemised them. "Direct" is the seller Google labels as the hotel's official site; for Park Plaza, Google showed no official label, so we used the brand's own site, parkplaza.com.
| Hotel | Sellers | Direct | Booking.com | Expedia | Cheapest seller | Cheapest vs direct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bellagio, Las Vegas | 22 | $446.50 | $468.03 (+4.8%) | $446.50 (0%) | Vio.com, $387.36 | −13.2% |
| Park Plaza Westminster Bridge, London | 28 | $590.24* | $590.24 (0%) | $587.50 (−0.5%) | Super.com, $461.23 | −21.9% |
| Palmer House Hilton, Chicago | 20 | $220.00 | $220.00 (0%) | $221.00 (+0.5%) | HotelsCombined, $173.00 | −21.4% |
| Pullman Paris Tour Eiffel | 34 | $458.91* | $458.91 (0%) | $456.77 (−0.5%) | Traveluro, $389.91 | −15.0% |
| Hotel Arts Barcelona | 23 | $517.25* | $517.25 (0%) | $517.19 (0%) | Super.com, $460.45 | −11.0% |
| Hilton Tokyo | 26 | $370.34 | $370.35 (0%) | $369.05 (−0.3%) | Traveluro, $357.00 | −3.6% |
* Members-only rate.
Two more hotels in our sample returned no comparison:
- Fontainebleau Miami Beach listed only five small resellers that night, with no official site and none of the large booking sites. Their prices ran from $1,595.50 to $2,116.00, a 33% spread for the same room-night.
- New York Hilton Midtown showed no prices at all for that date.
What this means
For travellers: if a price is far below the hotel's own site, it almost certainly comes with conditions: no free cancellation, prepayment, or a reseller you've never heard of handling your booking. For a flexible booking, the hotel's own rate was never more expensive than Booking.com or Expedia in our sample, and at the Bellagio it was the cheaper refundable option.
For hotels: parity between your website and the big booking sites mostly holds, but it is not the whole picture. Most of the undercutting comes from the long tail of resellers, which often get their inventory through wholesale or bed-bank contracts rather than directly from the hotel. Those prices sit right next to yours on Google. One check of a single night showed every hotel in our sample being undercut somewhere.
For revenue managers: a "parity check" that only looks at Booking.com and Expedia would have flagged two problems in this sample (Bellagio on Booking.com, Hilton Tokyo on Hotels.com and Agoda). It would have missed six undercutting resellers, one per hotel.
Method
- Stay: check-in Tuesday 8 December 2026, one night, two adults.
- View: United States market, prices in USD.
- Collected: 9 November 2026, one request per hotel, using the ScraperCompany Google Hotels API (
POST /v1/offers), which returns every seller Google Hotels lists for a stay, with base rate, taxes and total kept separate. - Comparison basis: each seller's total per night as displayed. Sellers itemise taxes differently. Where the cheapest seller didn't itemise tax and the hotel's own site did, we used the next-cheapest seller that did; this happened for Hilton Tokyo, where a seller showed $354.00 without tax.
- Hotels: eight well-known hotels in seven cities, chosen before we saw any prices. This is a snapshot of one night, not a statistical sample of the market. Prices change many times a day.
The full table of 168 offers for the six hotels with a direct price is available as a CSV download.
FAQ
Is it cheaper to book a hotel directly? In our snapshot of eight hotels, the hotel's own website cost the same as Booking.com and Expedia within about 1% at five of the six hotels that showed a direct price. It was 4.8% cheaper than Booking.com at the Bellagio, and about 9% cheaper than Hotels.com and Agoda at Hilton Tokyo.
Why are some booking sites cheaper than the hotel itself? Smaller resellers often sell rooms they buy through wholesale contracts, and some pass on part of their margin to win the click. In our data, those rates were up to 22% below the hotel's own price, and none came with free cancellation.
Do hotels have to charge the same price everywhere? No law requires it. Some contracts between hotels and booking sites include "rate parity" clauses, and their legal status varies by country. Several European countries restrict them.
How can a hotel see every price it's sold at? Google Hotels lists most sellers for a property side by side. A rate-parity check compares the hotel's own booking engine against each of them for many nights at once. See how to check hotel rate parity, or request our free rate parity check.